We Know Rentals. Get to Know Us

At Magic City Property Management we know the local real estate market in Muncie better than anyone else. After all, it’s our home too! Our professional and friendly team has been matching the right people with the right properties, and we want to do the same for you.

We make it a point to be involved and stay involved through all the stages of the property transaction process. Whether you’re looking to rent or have someone else manage, we promise to work hard on your behalf to ensure you get the best deal possible.

​

Why "Magic City"? The Story Behind the Name

As a proud Muncie native, I chose the name Magic City Properties to honor the deep roots and rich history of the place I call home. The nickname "Magic City" dates back to the late 1800s, during the Indiana Gas Boom — a time when Muncie transformed almost overnight. After natural gas was discovered in the region, industries sprang up, jobs multiplied, and the population exploded. It felt like the town had been touched by something extraordinary — like it had turned to gold in a moment’s time. That rapid growth and sudden prosperity earned Muncie the nickname “The Magic City,” a title that still holds a certain shimmer if you ask me.

But Muncie's magic isn't just in its past — it's in the resilience of its people, the warmth of its neighborhoods, and the stories passed down from generation to generation. From Ball State University to our beloved local businesses, Muncie remains a place of transformation, opportunity, and grit. At Magic City Properties, that spirit runs deep. We're not just managing homes — we’re preserving the legacy of a town that knows how to rise, rebuild, and shine again and again. Because once you've felt the magic of Muncie, it stays with you.